Related Topics
Stocks , US Markets

Are Stocks in Trouble? Here’s an (Almost) Sure-Fire Sign

Fractured markets tend to be unhealthy markets

by Bob Stokes
Updated: January 04, 2023

When the major stock indexes begin to act differently from each other, otherwise known as a fractured market, this is usually a sign of an unhealthy market.

We've seen this time and again, including just before one of the biggest bear markets in modern times.

On Sept. 14, 2007 our U.S. Short Term Update mentioned the upward price action in the blue-chip indexes, then showed this chart and said:


While the DJIA and S&P retained a bid, the NASDAQ lagged badly, failing to confirm the blue-chip rally by remaining beneath its Wednesday high (NASDAQ 100). A fractured market is oftentimes an unhealthy market and the divergent behavior yesterday remains consistent with the view that the entire [upward] push is countertrend, an opinion that we have maintained.

Less than a month later, the Dow Industrials hit a then all-time high before sliding into a bear market which saw the senior index lose more than half of its value.

Now consider this analysis from our U.S. Short Term Update:

The dichotomy of performance between the U.S. stock indexes is becoming pronounced. While the DJIA and S&P 500 are at new highs, the NASDAQ is lagging. Moreover, the Russell 2000, S&P MidCap 400 and Value Line Composite, are well below their prior highs on November 8. We'll see how these fractured trends resolve in the early part of the new year.

You may be interested in knowing that this analysis was provided on Dec. 29, 2021.

Less than a week later, the Dow Industrials and S&P 500 hit their most recent all-time highs and have been in a downtrend since.

Why is all this relevant now?

Well, our Dec. 28, 2022 U.S. Short Term Update presented a chart titled "A Fractured Trend Leads to Further Selling" with an explanation of the behavior differences between the major stock indexes.

Our Dec. 30 U.S. Short Term Update followed up by saying:

As memorable as 2022 may be for investors, it is just the appetizer to the main course...

Get the complete details by following the link below.

What's YOUR Investing Timeframe?

Near-term? Intermediate? Long-Term?

Our flagship Financial Forecast Service covers all three! So consider this headline from our recently published December Elliott Wave Theorist (part of our Financial Forecast Service):

"Another Approaching Twilight for Managed Money"

Read the explanation which accompanies that headline -- plus get near-term, intermediate and long-term coverage of U.S. stocks, bonds, gold, silver, the U.S. dollar, the U.S. economy and more.

Follow the link below so you can financially prepare for what may be ahead for 2023.

Financial Forecast Service


All month long, Financial Forecast Service helps you stay ahead of the waves in the U.S. markets on the timeframes that matter the most. FFS covers the stock indexes, bonds, gold, silver, the U.S. dollar, as well as market psychology and cultural trends. It is our most popular service.

Comprises the monthly Elliott Wave Financial Forecast, 3x-per-week Short Term Update and at least 12x-per-year Elliott Wave Theorist.

The Treasury Bond: We Forecast the Turn From a 12-Year Low (plus what followed)

October 2022 saw a huge turn in Treasury Bonds. The turbulence since then includes the banking sector crisis. See our forecast on the day of this pivotal juncture -- plus what exactly what our Short Term Update has said in the time since.

Wheat Had the Ultimate Bullish Boost – War! So Why Did It Go Bust Instead?

When Russia invaded Ukraine, news stories said "no end in sight" to the spike in wheat prices. Yet prices soon went bust. Why? See the contrary chart and commentary we showed Commodity Pro Service subscribers.


PTPC: The Stock Market is Riskier Than Economists Realized

Everyone knows financial markets are risky. But just how risky are they? Economists thought they knew, but it turns out that they had underestimated market risk by several orders of magnitude. Discover why and learn about a perspective that can help you get a better grasp on risks in the markets and everyday life.