Many late-comers to the silver party were trampled by last week's mad rush out the door.
A scene like that eventually happens after a market's prices go up exponentially. That was the story in silver -- it was up eight of the past nine months at the end of April.
Speculative fever burned hottest toward the end. Daily buying volume on the iShare Silver Trust (ETF) set a one-day record shortly before the top. As the head of trading for one brokerage firm put it, "Day traders are going crazy."
And soon another kind of crazy set in: Silver fell 30% in five trading days.
The April Elliott Wave Financial Forecast (published April 1) warned subscribers:
"...silver’s rise is no secret...A bullion dealer can conceive of no possible rationale for lower silver prices: 'If the economy recovers, that’s very good for silver because there will be huge industrial demand. If the economy is doing badly then people will buy silver as a store of value.' Somehow, he forgets that silver does, in fact, go down...The just stated rationale says silver should be owned no matter what. But the waves say this is a bad bet."
Even so, some silver analysts still sing silver's praises. Dow-Jones Marketwatch (5/9) quoted a precious metals book author who said, "seasoned investors and speculators understand that last week’s 34% correction in silver had nothing to do with any major changes in silver’s overall fundamentals or long-term outlook...They understood that silver was temporarily over-bought and the tipping point was the unprecedented margin increases by the exchange."
Do "margin requirements" explain the metal's swift price tumble? The just-published May
Financial Forecast says:
"Let's be clear: Margin hikes are not causing silver to decline. Gold is down...from its recent high and no one is complaining about its margin requirements...Not all big margin requirement increases coincide with silver turns, but the parallel between now and the 1980 peak is striking."
The Dow-Jones Marketwatch article also had this from a chief market strategist: "Despite the [silver] sell-off the big picture trend is higher...Too many people are being convinced that the recent rally was a bubble."
If silver's exponential rise wasn't a bubble, then exactly what was it? Were traders responding rationally to "silver's overall fundamentals," as the book author claimed? Let's return to the May
Financial Forecast:
"Try as they might, silver speculators will not be able to bring back the bubble."
Investors who believe that silver's decline is a buying opportunity will be well served by reading the May
Financial Forecast -- which begins with a
Special Section on silver. You can also read our latest analysis on gold.