Robert Prechter Dispels 10 Popular Investment Myths, Part VI

Home > Stocks
Robert Prechter Dispels 10 Popular Investment Myths, Part VI
The world's foremost Elliott wave practitioner tests economists' “Claim #5: 'GDP drives stock prices.'”

By Vadim Pokhlebkin
Mon, 20 Dec 2010 12:30:00 ET

Get investable insights sent to your inbox at least once a week – for free. Challenge the way you think about investing with The EWI Independent.

Privacy

This is Part VI of the series "Robert Prechter Dispels 10 Popular Investment Myths," where EWI president explains why traditional financial models failed -- and why they are doomed to fail again (and again). (Excerpted from Prechter's February and March 2010 Elliott Wave Theorists.)

Here are Part I, Part II, Part III, Part IV and Part V; come back later this week for Part VII.

The Socionomic Theory of Finance

The Conventional Error of Exogenous Cause and Rational Reaction

By Robert Prechter

Claim #5: “GDP drives stock prices.”

Surely the stock market reflects the nation’s Gross Domestic Product. The aggregate success of corporations shows up as changes in GDP. Stocks are shares in corporations. How could their prices not reflect the ebb and flow of GDP?

Suppose that you had perfect foreknowledge that over the next 3¾ years GDP would be positive every single quarter and that one of those quarters would surprise economists in being the strongest quarterly rise in a half-century span. Would you buy stocks?

If you had acted on such knowledge in March 1976, you would have owned stocks for four years in which the DJIA fell 22%. If at the end of Q1 1980 you figured out that the quarter would be negative and would be followed by yet another negative quarter, you would have sold out at the bottom.

Suppose you were to possess perfect knowledge that next quarter’s GDP will be the strongest rising quarter for a span of 15 years, guaranteed. Would you buy stocks?

Had you anticipated precisely this event for 4Q 1987, you would have owned stocks for the biggest stock market crash since 1929. GDP was positive every quarter for 20 straight quarters before the crash and for 10 quarters thereafter. But the market crashed anyway. Three years after the start of 4Q 1987, stock prices were still below their level of that time despite 30 uninterrupted quarters of rising GDP.

Figure 10 shows these two events. It seems that there is something wrong with the idea that investors rationally value stocks according to growth or contraction in GDP.

Interest rates, oil prices, trade balances, corporate earnings and GDP: None of them seem to be important, or even relevant, to explaining stock price changes. But you need not trust your own eyes. In a study that is stunning for its boldness in actually checking basis premises, Cutler, Poterba and Summers in a paper for the Journal of Portfolio Management in 1989 investigated the effect of economic news on stock prices and concluded, “Macroeconomic news bearing on fundamental values…explains only about one fifth of the movement in stock prices.”

Even here, I would question the conclusion that such news “explains” even 1/5 of the movement in stock prices. Surely a set of football statistics could generate a 1/5 correlation to the S&P. And every correlation, to have meaning, must have a theory to account for it. What theory accommodates the idea that macroeconomic fundamentals explain 1/5 of stock price changes? If there is no accommodating theory, then the presumed causality involved is tenuous at best. ..

[Part VII is now posted: Robert Prechter tests economists' “Claim #6: 'Wars are bullish/bearish for stock prices.'”]

Latest from Prechter: The December Elliott Wave Theorist gives you important updates on stocks, gold, silver as well as several stunning charts, including one that shows a reading so extreme it hasn't been seen in 45 years. Subscribe risk-free now for instant online access.

Tags: crude oil, earnings, Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH), Elliott Wave Principle, fundamental analysis, gross domestic product (GDP), inflation, Robert Prechter, S&P 500

May 13-16

Las Vegas Money Show

July 10-13

Freedom Fest Conference

Stay Ahead of the Trend in U.S. Stocks

EWI's Financial Forecast Service equips you to think, trade and invest independently from the crowd. Here's what you'll get, risk-free:

Short Term Update -- Intensive forecasts and analysis 3x/week for U.S. stocks, gold, silver, bonds and the U.S. dollar.
Financial Forecast -- In-depth, intermediate-term perspective on U.S. stocks, gold, silver, bonds and the U.S. dollar.
Theorist -- Bob Prechter's monthly big-picture insights.

Put the Financial Forecast Service on your screen in minutes, risk-free>>

Most Read

Highest Rated

Free Video Course

Learn the Why, What and How of Elliott Wave Analysis

Financial media use news and economic events to explain market moves. Steer clear of this misguided approach. Take part in the Elliott Wave Crash Course to learn what really moves the markets.

CLOSE [ X ]

The Elliott Wave Principle is a detailed description of how financial markets behave. The description reveals that mass psychology swings from pessimism to optimism and back in a natural sequence, creating specific Elliott wave patterns in price movements. Each pattern has implications regarding the position of the market within its overall progression, past, present and future. The purpose of Elliott Wave International’s market-oriented publications is to outline the progress of markets in terms of the Wave Principle and to educate interested parties in the successful application of the Wave Principle. While a course of conduct regarding investments can be formulated from such application of the Wave Principle, at no time will Elliott Wave International make specific recommendations for any specific person, and at no time may a reader, caller or viewer be justified in inferring that any such advice is intended. Investing carries risk of losses, and trading futures or options is especially risky because these instruments are highly leveraged, and traders can lose more than their initial margin funds. Information provided by Elliott Wave International is expressed in good faith, but it is not guaranteed. The market service that never makes mistakes does not exist. Long-term success trading or investing in the markets demands recognition of the fact that error and uncertainty are part of any effort to assess future probabilities. Please ask your broker or your advisor to explain all risks to you before making any trading and investing decisions.