Credit Where It is Due
Benoit Mandelbrot’s cover article in
Scientific American (February 1999, "A Multifractal Walk
Down Wall Street")1 is a good read and contains
important knowledge. His only omission is in properly
crediting most of the ideas presented therein to Ralph
Nelson Elliott, who put them forth more comprehensively, and
more accurately with respect to real-world markets,
sixty-one years ago in his book, The Wave Principle.2
Figure 1 shows R.N. Elliott’s depictions
from 1938 of the fractal nature of markets. Figure 2 shows
Mandelbrot’s from 1999. Figure 3 shows a figure photocopied
directly from Elliott’s literature. Figure 4 shows
Scientific American’s depiction of Mandelbrot’s thesis.
It is important to understand that slight differences in the
specific pattern used in these diagrams are irrelevant
because Mandelbrot is not arguing a specific form, just
multifractal self-affinity.
Continue with Prechter's
Response
Scientific
Controversy Introduction -
Mandelbrot's Article - Prechter's
Letter to the Editor
Prechter's Response -
Follow-up Responses
-
Socionomics