Elliott Wave International Shopping Cart
Main Subscribers Store Club EWI Education Info
Education
Welcome Center
A quick but thorough introduction to the Wave Principle and EWI for new wavers.
Message Board
(Formerly EWI Billboard)
Submit comments and questions to our analysts, or read what others have to say.
EWI  Basic Tutorial
For Subscribers and Club EWI members only:
Take the basic 10-lesson tutorial to Elliott waves.
EWI Advanced Tutorial
For Subscribers only:
A 10-lesson tutorial that builds on everything you've learned in the Basic Tutorial.
Books
All the titles every waver needs to grasp the Wave Principle and Socionomics.
Videos
Learn the Wave Principle with our complete 10 video set.
Conferences
Now's your chance to meet and speak with the world's top Elliotticians.

 

Credit Where It is Due 

Benoit Mandelbrot’s cover article in Scientific American (February 1999, "A Multifractal Walk Down Wall Street")1 is a good read and contains important knowledge. His only omission is in properly crediting most of the ideas presented therein to Ralph Nelson Elliott, who put them forth more comprehensively, and more accurately with respect to real-world markets, sixty-one years ago in his book, The Wave Principle.2

Figure 1 shows R.N. Elliott’s depictions from 1938 of the fractal nature of markets. Figure 2 shows Mandelbrot’s from 1999. Figure 3 shows a figure photocopied directly from Elliott’s literature. Figure 4 shows Scientific American’s depiction of Mandelbrot’s thesis. It is important to understand that slight differences in the specific pattern used in these diagrams are irrelevant because Mandelbrot is not arguing a specific form, just multifractal self-affinity.

 

 


Continue with Prechter's Response

Scientific Controversy Introduction  -  Mandelbrot's Article  - Prechter's Letter to the Editor
 Prechter's Response
- Follow-up Responses  -  Socionomics